Tommy Sheppard

MP for Edinburgh East

EU Withdrawal Bill Update - 23rd November

Westminster-colour

So the EU Withdrawal Bill was back in the Commons for Day 3 of the committee stage this week and, as promised, I’m writing to update you on what happened.

Before I talk about the Bill itself, you might be interested in the events of Monday’s Ways and Means debate. Ways and Means is a traditional term for taxes or other charges levied on the public in order to fund Government spending. And while not directly linked to the EU Withdrawal Bill, Brexit transcends everything. In an alternative attempt to get the UK to consider staying in the single market with access to the customs union the Labour MP for Edinburgh South, Ian Murray, had tabled an amendment that was selected for a vote.

The amendment to the Taxation (Cross Border Trade) Bill would have prevented taxes being charged on imports to the UK after Brexit. Due to World Trade Organisation rules, this would have effectively kept the UK in the customs union.  Yet the Labour Party fell into disarray as their front bench voted with the Tories and other MPs reported being told they weren’t needed to vote.  Fewer than 30 Labour MPs joined us in supporting Ian’s proposal and ultimately it was defeated by 311 votes to 76.

Tuesday’s debate focused on the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. My position, and that of the SNP, is that the charter must, absolutely, be enshrined in UK law. There are a number of rights in this charter that are not currently in UK law and there is no reason why these shouldn’t be retained after Brexit – including, for example, rights on child labour and the right to be forgotten on the internet.

I spoke in the debate and you can watch my contribution here * I've just been informed that this link is broken. I have contacted Parliament TV and I'm hoping it will be fixed quickly).  In the meantime you can read it in Hansard. I raised my concern that, as Joni Mitchell says, “You don’t know what you’ve got till it’s gone”. We take so many of these rights for granted, and rightly, don’t notice them in our day to day lives.

It’s not necessary to lose these rights to achieve Brexit but the Tories and DUP were out in force to defeat any amendment that would protect them.

In a successful attempt to quash potential backbench Tory rebels, May’s Government promised to review the way in which human rights would be affected by Brexit. That seemed to be enough. Dominic Grieve withdrew his amendment which called for the rights to be transferred into UK law and the rest fell into line behind him - so less rebellion and more a damp squib that could be easily be extinguished.

So what votes did happen?  We voted on New Clause 70 which would have ensured that parliament was informed of changes in EU and European Economic Area provisions that might have amended UK laws around family-friendly employment rights and gender equality, and their potential impact. It was defeated by 314 votes to 295. 

The Tory Government had its smallest majority yet at only 10 votes on amendment 46 - to retain the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights in UK law. I’m sure the Lords will have something to say about this. A second amendment which would have retained the principles of EU law in domestic law was also defeated – this time by 19 votes.

So another frustrating day with the Tory rebels bought off for now.

Yesterday, Brexit was my focus again but this time in Cabinet Office Questions. The Cabinet Office are meant to be overseeing the whole process of the UK leaving the EU. For months now I’ve been asking for details on the number of civil servants being employed to do this work and how much it will cost. After another unsuccessful written parliamentary question, I used my opportunity to ask about it in the chamber. But I still didn’t receive a proper response – you can watch it here.

As I mentioned in my last blog, the Scottish Affairs Select Committee report on the devolution of powers following Brexit was published last weekend. This report was approved by all parties on the committee (including the Tories) and raised serious concerns about the impact of the EU Withdrawal Bill on Scotland’s devolution settlement. It called for the UK Government to take urgent action to improve the Bill and provide clarity about the implications of their legislation for Scotland. You can read the full report here.

We now have a slight break in proceedings as next week we’ll be debating yesterday’s budget. Day 4 of the EU Withdrawal Bill debate takes place on 4th December with Day 5 on the 6th – on both days we’ll be moving on to discuss the clauses that most directly affect devolution.

 

 

Budget Debate
Question on the cost of Brexit

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Sunday, 25 February 2018

Tommy's Blog Articles

Tommy Sheppard
21 February 2018
Tommy's Blog
My work for you in Westminster
Contributions

The Scottish Government is already giving EU citizens the right to vote in Scottish Parliament elections. At today's Cabinet Office questions I asked the UK Government to extend the right to vote to all those legally living here.

 

Tommy Sheppard
04 February 2018
My work for you in Edinburgh East
Tommy's Blog
Policy
My work for you in Westminster
You may be aware that last week the Scottish Government implemented an effective ban on electronic shock collars for dogs. These are barbaric devices that have no place in the training of dogs. I congratulate Ben Macpherson MSP on his campaign to get this action. However, the Scottish Government have one hand tied behind their back as powers over the sale of such devices is reserved to Westminster...
Tommy Sheppard
29 January 2018
Tommy's Blog
My work for you in Westminster
Contributions

Given the numerous, and pretty serious, incidents in Edinburgh East on Bonfire Night I was very happy to take part in the Westminster Hall debate on an e-petition relating to fireworks. Here's a few clips from the speech.

Fireworks Debate - 29th Jan 18

 

Roz Currie
26 January 2018
Tommy's Blog
Press Release - Friday 26th JanuarySNP politicians are calling on the Tory government at Westminster to use its reserved powers to ban the sale of electronic shock collars across the UK.   Leading animal welfare groups united this week to praise the SNP Scottish Government’s decision to use its devolved powers to introduce a “prompt and effective” ban on the use of shock collars and other forms of...
Tommy Sheppard
26 January 2018
Tommy's Blog
Contributions

Here's my speech at the Council of Europe urgent debate on Palestine. Trump's recent actions have made America's role as a mediator untenable. It now falls to Europe to step up to find a solution for Israel and Palestine.