Tommy Sheppard

MP for Edinburgh East

Four great candidates, one great big decision – and members must make it

Four great candidates, one great big decision – and members must make it

Tomorrow is the second anniversary of the first independence referendum. Getting ready for the second one is providing the backdrop against which SNP members are selecting a new Depute Leader.

Ballot papers go out in four days’ time to more than 100,000 members eligible to vote in the contest. Campaigning by the four candidates began six weeks ago, and the contest has certainly been thorough.

In my last column before the ballot opens I want to pay tribute to my fellow candidates who have made this a dignified and positive campaign, and to the thousands of party members who have attended hustings across the country.

But first, let’s talk about the job. SNP members can go online and check out the party’s website to see what the rulebook says about the post. They won’t find much. A single paragraph defines the role as to deputise for the leader (no surprises there) and to prepare the manifesto.

That’s why each of the candidates have put their own interpretation on the job and will, if elected, put a personal stamp on how it gets done. So members have to choose not just who they want to do the job but what job they want done.

For me, this is about more than standing in for the leader when she’s not available; it’s a job in itself. I believe our main challenge as a party is to consolidate the recent changes in Scottish politics and galvanise our new membership. That will require changing how we do things and I want to lead that change, aiming to give our party an organisational upgrade.

This isn’t just desirable, it is necessary if we are to get match-fit to lead and win the next referendum. Our mass membership is our strength.

Whether they’ve been a member for just a few months or a lifetime, I want many more people to be active in our party.

Over the last few weeks I’ve laid out in detail how I’d like to see our party develop. How we can refocus our branches, communicate better with ourselves, and involve our members in making the policies that will shape our future. Check my website at if you missed any of this – it’s all still there. The SNP is, in electoral terms, already the most successful political party in Europe. But we can be better still. I’m seeking a mandate to begin the process of strengthening our organisation, diverting 10 per cent of our income to new organisers throughout the country.

But other candidates are available.

Chris McEleny is the leader of the SNP group on Inverclyde Council. He makes the not unreasonable point that our champions in local government have often been overlooked in our party’s structure and management. And he makes it well. Whatever happens I predict an enhanced role for councillors within our party at local and national level, all the more necessary if we succeed next year in controlling a majority of Scotland’s local authorities.

Angus Robertson, the party’s Westminster leader, argues the depute position would cement the links between our two parliamentary groups. He points out, correctly, that he has the edge over the rest of us in terms of internal party experience. The thing is, Angus is doing a great job as our leader in Westminster: why would anyone want him to be distracted from it by taking on a second party job?

Alyn Smith has represented Scotland in the European Parliament since 2004. Post-Brexit, he argues that Scotland’s constitutional future now centres on discussions with other EU countries. Being Depute would, he claims, give him the additional heft and status required to drive those negotiations forward. It’s a fair enough point, although Alyn will of course remain our main man in Europe anyway for the next four years.

Four great candidates. One decision. Like I say, you need to first decide what job you want done. At the hustings some have argued that the role of depute should be “whatever the leader wants”, others that candidates’ existing relationship with our First Minister should be a criterion. But if that were the case we wouldn’t be having an election. Whoever becomes depute will offer complete loyalty and support to our leader, and will work to their direction. But, unlike other posts, this one is not appointed by the leader. Which is exactly why Nicola Sturgeon has made it clear she is not endorsing anyone.

Others have pointed to their support from MPs or MSPs (the majority of whom aren’t declaring either way) as a reason to support them. But this position isn’t appointed by parliamentarians either. No, this is a decision for each and every member of our party. It is our mass membership who should decide what this job should be and who should do it. This election should reflect members’ views – no-on else’s.

SNP members have an opportunity in this election to add a new voice to our leadership team rather than stretch it. Watch out for those ballots in the inbox.

This column was written for The National - 17th September 2016

Developing a proper regional structure would make ...
Time to stop and think about our city’s future

Related Posts



No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Friday, 27 April 2018

Tommy's Blog Articles

Tommy Sheppard
26 April 2018
Tommy's Blog
Since the 30th March Palestinians in Gaza have been peacefully protesting. They will continue until the 15th May - the 70th anniversary of the Nakba, the name Palestinians have for the events that displaced them from their homes when Israel was created.The protests are billed as the “Great Return March” to make the point that it’s time to leave Gaza and go back to where they came from. But try tha...
Tommy Sheppard
29 March 2018
Tommy's Blog
We need to change the law on drugs. In fairness, that’s always been my view. But until now I’ve done little about it as an MP. Why? Partly because there’s always been something I’ve felt was a greater priority – and partly because I know well how views can be distorted and used against people in public life.But that changes now. Three different events over the past few weeks have made me realise t...
Tommy Sheppard
28 March 2018
Tommy's Blog
My work for you in Westminster

I asked the Minister if the government would require the Electoral Commission to disclose donations for parties in Northern Ireland from before 2015. This follows allegations of dark money from the Constitutional Research Council, which is linked to the Scottish Tories, to the DUP. As usual, no straight answer.


Tommy Sheppard
23 March 2018
My work for you in Edinburgh East
Tommy's Blog
Recently I visited the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh where I met the inspiring Resuscitation Research Group who are developing innovative approaches to improving the outcomes for out-of-hospital cardiac arrests.The group told me that every year in Scotland more than three and a half thousand people suffer a cardiac arrest, and unfortunately survival rates are very low at just one in twenty....
Tommy Sheppard
21 March 2018
Tommy's Blog
My work for you in Westminster

The Secretary of State for Northern Ireland is unable to answer my question on the Irish Border. Legitimate questions deserve proper answers not the same old Tory rhetoric.