Tommy Sheppard

MP for Edinburgh East

It's better to be led by the left while we're in UK


Dearie me, what’s going on in the People’s Party? First, shadow chancellor John McDonnell states that a Westminster Labour government wouldn’t block a request from the Scottish Parliament to hold an independence referendum. He says it twice just in case anyone thinks the first time was a mistake. And this week Jeremy Corbyn says it again to be sure.

Now, in one sense, it’s an unremarkable statement. But strangely it seems to have caused apoplectic rage in Labour’s Scottish ranks. This summer’s red-on-red action marks a further step in the journey to irrelevance by this once great party.

It’s hard to see what all the fuss is about. No-one expects Labour to support independence. Nor to support having a referendum on the question. What democrats should expect is that a party committed to allowing people here to decide their own future would respect any decisions taken by majority vote in the Scottish Parliament.

That’s all McDonnell and Corbyn said. In stating the blindingly obvious they are paying rather more attention to Scottish public opinion than their Scottish lieutenants - people so far inside their own bunker they cannot see what is going on around them.

Latest polls show not only that support for independence is over 50% and rising, but that a majority favour asking the question sooner rather than later. More significant is the split by party, as 40% of Labour supporters in Scotland also say they support political independence for our country.

That’s four in ten of thoses who would still vote Labour – not those who used to. When you consider significant layers of former Labour support has switched to the SNP precisely because of its stance on independence it is not unreasonable to suggest that a sizeable majority of the people Labour should be aiming to win over are pro-Indy.

That is why McDonnell is trying to signal a more relaxed stance on the question. He knows that if they’re too dogmatic and set their face resolutely against even discussing independence they risk losing further support. And of course he is all too aware of the political damage done to Labour following their alliance with the Tories last time round. In many ways Labour’s London leadership is trying to save the party in Scotland from itself. Good luck with that.

Labour Unionists will tell you that it’s not that they object in principle to a referendum. They say, after all, that they support the Claim of Right which states that people in Scotland have the right to decide the manner in which they are governed. No, the argument is that there’s already been a referendum and no-one wants another one.

Really? How do they know?

How would anyone judge whether people who live in Scotland want to review the decision to stay in the UK taken in 2014? There’s the opinion polls of course. But these can be partial, inaccurate and ephemeral.

I know: what if there was a General Election to the Scottish national parliament? And what if the question of whether to have a referendum was a central issue in that election with different parties arguing for and against? And what if that election returned a majority of representatives on a mandate of having a referendum? Surely then it would only be fair and democratic for that majority to execute its central policy.

This is not an abstract or theoretical question. This actually happened. In 2016. Mandate extant.

This week, the SNP have been clear that they could support a minority Labour administration at Westminster. Again, nothing new here. At the last two elections the SNP has argued for a progressive alternative to the Tories if the cards dealt by the electorate make that possible.

The SNP are a left-of-centre party. Not till hell freezes over would we support keeping the Tories in power (note to self, LibDems). Whilst we remain part of the UK, it is better for Scotland that it is governed from the left.

When we become an independent country that will be even more the case. Why would be want anything other than for our nearest neighbour to be led by a government espousing the same sort of social justice and public interest economic policies as we aspire to here? That is not to say that Jeremy Corbyn gets a blank cheque – but simply that there’s deal to be done.

Doubtless there will be some unionist conspiracy theorists thinking that there’s some linkage between the Labour leadership position on a Scottish referendum and the SNP’s tentative support should they need it. There isn’t.

Both are long-standing positions by either party, admittedly given topical relevance by the imminence of a General Election. And both are decent, fair and common sense answers to hypothetical, but probable, questions. Sometimes two groups of people can do the right thing by coincidence.

Written for the Sunday National - 18th August 2019

In the coming election we must tackle Unionist myt...
Why criticism of Edinburgh festival must be taken ...


No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Wednesday, 22 January 2020

Captcha Image

Tommy's Blog Articles

Tommy Sheppard
03 January 2020
Tommys Blog
Is it just me or does last month’s election already seem a long time ago? That last week in parliament was a pretty turgid affair. Self-congratulation by the tea-room Tories was matched by remorse and recrimination as Labour losers cleared lockers and desks. And then it was Christmas. There was no settling of the dust, no clarity on what the election results actually meant.That starts now. Not for...
Tommy Sheppard
13 September 2019
Tommys Blog
At two minutes past ten on Wednesday morning I was sitting in court number one just behind St Giles on the Royal Mile. A minute later Lord Carloway announced the unanimous decision by the appeal court judges that the British government had acted illegally in proroguing parliament.  There was an audible intake of breath as the decision hit.I was pleased to join my colleague Joanna Cherry QC, and ot...
Tommy Sheppard
09 September 2019
Tommys Blog
My work for you in Westminster
I've had a few emails recently from people who are asking about the SNP position regarding a general election.While I recorded some video updates last week, one of the limitations of social media is that it mitigates against context and nuance, so it is not always an adequate medium to communicate one's ideas. Also, while the instant nature of social media is useful it is limited in a situation li...
Tommy Sheppard
03 September 2019
Tommys Blog
Under the new Prime Minister, the UK’s headlong dash towards the No Deal Brexit cliff edge has accelerated. Johnson makes demands he knows the European Union cannot accept. He demands the removal of the Backstop. The Backstop was designed to protect the Good Friday Agreement and thus peace in Northern Ireland and is, let’s not forget, an international treaty which is overwhelmingly supported by th...
Tommy Sheppard
26 August 2019
Tommys Blog
And so the parliamentary summer recess draws to a close. This week Westminster opposition parties meet to plan their autumn attack. The week after, battle commences in the palace by the Thames. The parliament and the premier, each with a death wish on each other. The question: who will get the killer blow in first?What is clear is that a General Election is coming. Either the government will colla...