Tommy Sheppard

MP for Edinburgh East

May faces Tory civil war if UK becomes ‘EU colony’

westminster-PSDd

Well, as years go, 2017 wasn’t the greatest. Globally, the world became a much more precarious place.

Donald Trump got his feet under the Oval Office desk and spent most of the year insulting people almost everywhere. Ramping up international tensions he rattled some pretty big sabres at North Korea. The year finished with Trump firmly taking sides in the Middle East conflict, much to chagrin of pretty much every diplomat in the rest of the world.

Meanwhile in the UK things went from bad to worse over Brexit. Theresa May called an election nobody wanted, managing to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. In a desperate move to hang on to her premiership she bought the DUP – a hitherto relatively unknown, extreme Protestant party in Northern Ireland – for a billion quid.

As the full horror of Brexit started to unfold, people began to see the consequences of the choice the UK made to leave the EU in June 2016. A whole lot of things that weren’t on the ballot paper – jobs disappearing, firms closing, prices rising – appeared on the horizon. With her authority diminished, May ended the year agreeing to pretty much everything the Brussels negotiators wanted. She also agreed to a transitional phase which in effect means abiding by the rules of the single European market – even if she can say in a legal sense the UK is no longer a member.

As right-wing Tory John Redwood observed, this will be a bit like being an EU colony – having to follow all of the rules but without having any say. Indeed, John, you should have been careful about what you wished for. The reality is now beginning to dawn on most people that hoping to get a better trading deal with the EU after leaving than you had when you were part of it is an illogical fantasy. We know for sure things will be worse – the only question is by how much?

All of this political mess, across the world and across the Continent, makes the future seem uncertain, scary even. This is one of the reasons why the debate on the future government of our own country has to wait till things become more settled.
 
But for those hoping for stability soon I’m afraid disappointment looms. I hope you had a restful break and have recharged your batteries for the challenges of the year ahead. You’re going to need them. Just as you think things can only get better – my guess is there’s worse to come.
 
For starters, the government is weak – May lost three Cabinet Secretaries in the last two months of 2017. Normally, that would be a crisis in itself. But none of these resignations was connected to Brexit, and Brexit is the daddy of all catastrophes, so Theresa can keep her eyelids unbatted.
 
As we go into the next phase of how to make Brexit work, the government will have to try to get agreement with itself before seeking agreement with the EU. The Prime Minster will either have to upset the DUP – by agreeing to special border relationships on the island of Ireland – or her hard-right Brexiteers by aligning with single-market rules throughout the UK. Talk about a rock and a hard place.
 
It’ll not be pretty. And, as discussions proceed with the EU, it will become apparent that the future will be worse than the past. Meanwhile many who keep our public services and hospitality industry going are getting the government’s message that they are alien workers, not fellow European citizens, and voting with their feet. As all of this unfolds surely demands for the UK to think again will increase. If it doesn’t, we need to be ready in Scotland to consider a different path.

Column written for the Edinburgh Evening News - Thursday 4th January 2018
EU Withdrawal Bill Update - 21st December
EU Withdrawal Bill Update - 14th December

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Monday, 22 January 2018

Tommy's Blog Articles

Tommy Sheppard
18 January 2018
Tommy's Blog
My work for you in Westminster
This week Parliament was back debating the EU Withdrawal Bill as it entered the Report stage in the House of Commons. Before I update you on those debates, I want to let you know about a report the Scottish Government have published.On Monday the Scottish Government released its second paper on the potential implications of Brexit on Scotland and the options available to us.  Scotland’s Place in E...
Tommy Sheppard
14 December 2017
Tommy's Blog
Well we finally have it. The coalition were defeated in the House of Commons last night. Despite their attempts to cajole and bully their backbenchers, 11 Tories rebelled and Amendment 7 passed by just 4 votes.  And while Ministers are now jumping to say that it isn’t significant, that it’s only one vote and that Brexit is on track their faces told a very different story in the Chamber.This is imp...
Tommy Sheppard
11 December 2017
Tommy's Blog
It’s difficult to know where to start on last week’s Brexit developments. On Monday the Prime Minister was left scrabbling around after the DUP flexed their muscles and refused to agree the deal with the EU that would enable to them to move on to Phase 2 of negotiations.By the end of the week the deal was done and a joint statement was issued from the UK Government and negotiators from the Europea...
Tommy Sheppard
30 November 2017
My work for you in Edinburgh East
Tommy's Blog

I used my Evening News column this month to talk about fireworks following the extreme antisocial behaviour on bonfire night. I've also written to the Minister asking for the UK Government to toughen up licensing laws. And if they aren't willing to do that, devolve power over fireworks to the Scottish Parliament so they can act. Read the full article here.

 

Tommy Sheppard
30 November 2017
Tommy's Blog
My work for you in Westminster
The EU Withdrawal Bill entered its committee stage this month in the House of Commons.  As it is a constitutional bill it is considered by a committee of the whole house – in other words all MPs consider it in the main chamber. While hundreds of amendments were tabled, only a few are selected for a vote each day. There will be eight days of debate in total, three of which took place in November. O...