Tommy Sheppard

MP for Edinburgh East

Tories won’t grab our powers without a fight

Stronger-for-Scotland

Brexit rumbles on. Last week the SNP walked out of parliament in protest at not being allowed to discuss House of Lords amendments that will seriously affect how we are governed. If we can’t have our say inside the chamber we’ll make our arguments outside.

Meanwhile the UK government say we’re scaremongering. What power grab say the Tories? They claim that the Scottish government will get more powers after Brexit and not a single power it currently has will be removed. Is this true? Let’s see.

It is true that the Scottish Parliament will have responsibility for more things if Brexit happens. The problem is it’ll have a lot less power to do anything about them. The UK government is proposing that in 24 of the most significant and important areas – including the environment, agriculture and fishing – what Scotland does will need UK approval.

We have yet to see the details of how UK frameworks might operate in these areas. But we know the principles on which they’ll be based. And the principles are the problem.

Imagine a joint committee to coordinate agricultural policy for example. On that committee the interests of Scottish and Welsh farmers would be represented by the Scottish and Welsh governments. Since there is no English national government the interests of English farmers would need to be represented by the Department of Food and Rural Affairs, a department of the UK government.

So, what happens in a disagreement? Well, the UK government position is that DEFRA will have the final say. It will be the judge and jury in resolving any disputes. That means, in effect, that the wishes of the industry in England will prevail and the other nations of the UK will be subservient to them.

Does this really matter? Yes, it does. It means for example, that if the Scottish government wants to have a ban on GM crops to protect the reputation of Scotland’s larder, but English farmers wish a more relaxed policy, Scotland will lose out.

After years of lobbying, the Scottish government secured recognition of Scotland’s crofting industry and now uses EU CAP funds to support bespoke schemes. But this may not get the support of a committee dominated by large commercial farming interests in England.

And that’s only agriculture: there are 23 other policy areas where the same thing applies.

None of this is to suggest that people in England shouldn’t have control of things in their own country – of course they should. But the UK government cannot be both England’s representative and the arbiter of disputes. It’d be fairer to have an independent disputes procedure. But that suggestion by the Scottish government was dismissed by the UK – just one of the reasons discussions on post Brexit arrangements are at an impasse.

In these areas after Brexit Westminster will control the operation not only of new powers being repatriated from the EU, but existing ones that have been executed in Scotland without hindrance for decades. That’s why we call it a power grab.

You’ll hear people say that the reason why Scotland mustn’t be able to decide its own policies on agriculture or the environment is that it might somehow jeopardise UK trade deals. What nonsense. Are we really being told that a trade deal with the US or any other country cannot include a clause that recognises that the legislative framework in a relevant area is different in Scotland?

Perhaps the only area where trade is a relevant consideration is government operations and procurement itself. And there’s the rub. Should the Scottish government be able to choose to exempt our NHS from private competition for example?

Brexit could provide the opportunity to put these decisions in the hands of the government people in Scotland elected. But not with the EU Withdrawal Bill as currently drafted. So, we’ll keep up the arguments, inside or outside the House of Commons.

 

Written for Edinburgh Evening News - 21st June 2018

 

 

 

June Newsletter - Westminster
EU Withdrawal Bill Update - 15th June 2018

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Thursday, 19 July 2018

Tommy's Blog Articles

Tommy Sheppard
11 July 2018
Tommy's Blog
Media

We need to talk about democracy. The UK government recently hosted its first ever “National Democracy Week” – with no sense of irony.

We absolutely should be celebrating the 90th anniversary of the equalisation of voting ages for men and women. Nobody would argue with that.

Tommy Sheppard
21 June 2018
Tommy's Blog
Media
Brexit rumbles on. Last week the SNP walked out of parliament in protest at not being allowed to discuss House of Lords amendments that will seriously affect how we are governed. If we can’t have our say inside the chamber we’ll make our arguments outside.Meanwhile the UK government say we’re scaremongering. What power grab say the Tories? They claim that the Scottish government will get more powe...
Tommy Sheppard
15 June 2018
Tommy's Blog
Buckle up folks – here comes a bumper blog as this week saw the return of the EU Withdrawal Bill after its time in the Lords. Or, more accurately, we were back voting on the EU Withdrawal Bill given there was precious little time for any actual debate. Over two days we were supposed to debate and vote on 20 different changes to the Bill that the Lords had put forward.You’ll likely have seen and he...
Tommy Sheppard
19 May 2018
Tommy's Blog
Okay I know that it’s probably not the best time to try to start a discussion about the monarchy. With a popular prince wedding his celebrity sweetheart in a lavish event resplendent in the glitz and glamour of Hollywood, it might be best for dissidents like myself to keep our republican heads below the parapet.Then again, with the nation’s attention focused on the royals because of the wedding, t...
Tommy Sheppard
02 May 2018
Tommy's Blog
Media
This is a piece about the SNP’s constitutional review. Exciting, huh? Well, maybe not, but important all the same.I know – at least I hope – no-one joins a political party to debate its internal structure. And set against debates on Indy, Brexit and the World War III this is unlikely to get anyone’s political juices flowing. People are motivated by ideas and feelings, powerful emotions that propel...